Investment in Social Funds Leads to a Reduction in Charitable Donations

Written on | ,

Researchers warn that this substitution effect may impact charities negatively.

A new TAU study, the first of its kind, examined whether there is a connection between the rapid growth of investment in social investment funds and the decrease in donations to charitable organizations. The researchers studied the actual investment behavior of approximately 10,000 clients of an investment app, and found that investors switching to invest in a recently introduced social fund reduced their donations, mainly in charities supporting causes similar to those of the social fund.

However, the researchers also found that most of the investors in the social fund had not previously donated to charities, so, looking at the big picture, social funds entice more people to fund social causes.

The study was conducted by Dr. Shai Levi and Prof. Shai Danziger of Tel Aviv University’s Coller School of Management, in collaboration with Dr. Jake An of the Australian firm Raiz Investing and Prof. Donnel Briley of the University of Sydney. The study was published in the prestigious journal Management Science.

Charities Take a Hit

In recent years, investment firms have been marketing social investments (Environment, Society and Government, or ESG) as a way for investors to achieve financial returns while making a social impact. Such funds will for instance avoid investments in certain industries, like oil, and rather invest in others, like renewable energy.

In 2018, global social investment assets exceeded $30 trillion, an increase of 34% since 2016. During this same period, in the U.S., total donations to nonprofits – the traditional avenue for advancing social goals – dropped 1.1 percent to about $300 billion. Until now, the causal link between the popularity of social investments and the decline in charitable giving had not been examined.

Dr. Levi explains that the study was conducted using the unique database of the Australian digital investment platform Raiz Investment – a phone app aimed primarily at millennials, young investors with relatively small investment portfolios.

According to Dr. Levi, in 2017 Raiz added the option of investing in an ESG social fund, which invests only in companies that meet certain standards of sustainability, social values ​​and governance. Because the app is connected to users’ bank accounts, it was possible to monitor investors’ charitable donations both before and after they joined the fund. The researchers tracked the investments and donations of about 3,300 investors who invested in ESG, about 4,000 investors who invested in another, non-social fund, and another 3,300 investors in a control group, that were matched on investor characteristics to those that had switched to the ESG fund. They found that, on average, investors who contributed to charitable organizations before investing in a social fund tended to donate less afterwards – that is, some investors saw their ESG investment as a kind of donation.

Overall Effect Uncertain

Prof. Danziger points to the complexity of the findings. “On the one hand, investment firms could use social funds as a marketing ploy to attract investors. For example, say you’re told the ESG fund invests only in companies with a low carbon footprint – that doesn’t mean that you’re investing in companies in the field of renewable energy. It can mean that you’re investing in technology giants like Apple, that is, companies that are not necessarily causing damage. Our findings show that after investing in a social fund, investors reduce their traditional contributions to environmental and social nonprofits.”

“On the other hand, since 79% of investors in the ESG fund did not make any charitable contributions before investing, the overall effect must be assessed. Ultimately, the question is whether ESG contributions to society outweigh the decrease in investor donations that result from substitution. In our study, we estimate that overall, funds will have a positive impact on society only if their annual contribution to social causes exceeds 3.2% of the balance invested. In practice, this is difficult to measure, and we don’t know whether the contribution of the social funds crosses this threshold, so it is not clear whether their impact on society is positive.”

In conclusion, the researchers say, “The trend that emerged from the study indicates that investors may replace charities with social funds. This could have a major impact on charities, who will lose a significant source of income and find it difficult to continue to function.”

Related posts

BOG 2022: Arbib Entrance Plaza Named

May 19, 2022

Helping Thousands of Students and Alumni Job-hunt

May 18, 2022

BOG 2022: TAU Inaugurates Sagol Center for Regenerative Medicine

May 17, 2022

BOG 2022: TAU Inaugurates Koret Center for Jewish Civilization

May 16, 2022

BOG 2022: TAU Inaugurates Sylvan Adams Sports Center

May 14, 2022

BOG 2022: Exposing Hidden Truths from the Female Perspective

May 13, 2022

BOG 2022: TAU Awards Honorary Degrees to Change-Making Cohort

May 13, 2022

BOG 2022: Nine Winners Receive Reimagined Dan David Prize

May 12, 2022

This Week: TAU Welcomes Governors to Annual Meeting

May 10, 2022

On Israel’s Independence Day, TAU Celebrates Breakthroughs

May 3, 2022

New Collaborations between TAU and Leading Turkish Universities

April 29, 2022

TAU Launches Manufacturing Research Center in India

April 13, 2022

Strengthening Local Leadership in Israel

April 5, 2022

First Israeli Research Book Published in Abu Dhabi

April 3, 2022

TAU Welcomes Ukrainian Emergency Fellowship Students

March 31, 2022

Prof. Ehud Gazit – First Israeli to Receive Prestigious International Recognition in Chemistry

March 31, 2022

From War in Ukraine to Studies at TAU

March 20, 2022

TAU Special Briefing: Crisis in Ukraine

March 8, 2022

TAU Launches Emergency Fellowship Fund for Ukrainian Graduate Students

March 3, 2022

The New Dan David Prize Announces Inaugural Cohort of Winners

March 2, 2022

Prof. Oded Lipschits Awarded the 2022 EMET Prize in Archaeology

February 21, 2022

And Let There Be Light

February 6, 2022

More than 16,000 participants on TAU’s Open Day 2022

February 2, 2022

The Magnificent TAU Trees

January 16, 2022

For the 1st time at an Israeli university: Air and Space Power Center

January 4, 2022

First Anniversary of Morocco-USA-Israel Agreement

December 28, 2021

TAU Students Racing Towards a Greener Campus

December 21, 2021

TAU and Goethe University Establish Joint Center for Interfaith Studies

December 19, 2021

TAU Ventures Raises $50M to Boost Israeli Startups

December 12, 2021

Coexistence – Israel’s Inevitable Faith

December 6, 2021

Cybermania

November 30, 2021

Tel Aviv University and Rutgers University Strengthen Ties

November 29, 2021

TAU’s Tisch Film School Among Global Best

November 29, 2021

TAU 8th in World for Entrepreneurship

November 29, 2021

Climate Action: From Campus to Glasgow

November 26, 2021

TAU: First Israeli University to Launch Online MBA

November 18, 2021

Feeling at Home in Tanzania

November 13, 2021

Revisiting the Tel Aviv Zoo

November 12, 2021

TAU Initiates Model for Carbon Neutrality

November 11, 2021

Britain and Israel Team Up on Challenge of Healthy Ageing

November 10, 2021

Meet the New Academic Power Couple

November 10, 2021

TAU Launches Cutting-Edge Center for Innovation Labs

November 3, 2021

From Law and Education to Nursing

November 3, 2021

394 TAU Researchers Among World’s Top 100,000

October 31, 2021

TAU 5th in World for Entrepreneurship

October 28, 2021

Israel-Indian academic ties boosted by visit of Indian Minister of External Affairs

October 26, 2021

“In Wars, there are Winners and Losers. In Peace, Everyone Wins”

October 20, 2021

This Week: TAU Board of Governors Meeting 2021

October 11, 2021

Be My Guest

September 19, 2021

Prof. Isaac Ben-Israel Receives the IEEE Leadership Award

August 13, 2021

Pursuing the Unknown

Copyright ©  Tel Aviv University Trust. All rights reserved.
Registered charity number 314179.